Dinner with Mundie

One of the more enlightened things that Microsoft does to to maintain a really serious research effort, employing really first-rate people and giving them great freedom. This report of a dinner conversationw ith CEO Craig Mundie suggests that the policy will continue.

The centrally funded model for Microsoft Research is still right: This is especially interesting to me, because I have written two books on corporate research. I can tell you that funding a corporate research operation straight from central corporate coffers — as opposed to via contracts with various business divisions for work they want done — is almost unheard of in this day and age. That’s because most companies believe that in order for their research groups to have good ties to their business needs, labs need to get all, or at least a major part of, their funding from business divisions — for work the business divisions want done. Microsoft’s approach is to let MSR work without those strings, in order to keep researchers more unfettered and open to new things. "I still think that that was and remains a good strategy," Mundie told me. Over the years, many have questioned whether Microsoft’s investment in MSR has been worth it, and everyone from Gates to SVP of research Rick Rashid on down has steadfastly maintained it has been — with contributions to just about every Microsoft product. The way Mundie put it to me: MSR is “just becoming more and more integral.”

(Note: I am talking about research, the ‘R’ part of R&D. The vast majority of Microsoft’s roughly $9 billion annual investment in R&D is for development, with the research labs getting only a fraction of this amount.)

What the EU doesn’t get about Google: it’s a SEARCH engine

Lovely, sarcastic piece by Danny Sullivan about the EU’s attitude towards Google.

I did a search at Google today for “cars” and was shocked. Rather than list links allowing me to search for “cars” on Bing, Yahoo, Baidu, Voila, Naver and Yandex, Google instead favored its own search results. I’m glad the EU will be investigating whether this favoritism violates anti-trust laws….

Walled_Garden v0.7

Clearing out some books the other day, this AOL flyer from the early 1990s fell out of one volume. Reminder of a vanished age? Or a harbinger of a new one?

Quote of the day

“You are only as old and boring as the people you surround yourself with.”

John Brockman

That’s one of the reasons why it’s nice to work in a university.

Clochemerle-on-the-Liffey

One of the Irish newspapers last week (I forget which but the reporter was Pat Leahy) had a revealing little vignette from the Donegal South West by-election — which was won by the Sinn Fein candidate, and in which the Fianna Fail vote collapsed. Leahy reported a conversation he had with a constituent in which he asked her how she intended to vote. She replied that she and all her family would be voting for Fianna Fail, the architects of the current economic catastrophe. “Why?” asked Leahy. “Because Mary Coughlan [Deputy Prime Minister and one of the other TDs [MPs] for the constituency] got my mother into hospital”.

This (and my own story about my father’s death) tells you all you need to know about Irish politics. Parish-pump politicians are not the kind of people you need to run a modern state.

Why the Establishment hates the Net

This morning’s Observer column.

Two disconnected events last week showed how far we still have to go in understanding our new communications environment. In one, an Anglican bishop was suspended for some remarks he made on his Facebook page about the forthcoming wedding of two graduates of St Andrews University. In the other, a 27-year-old accountant had his appeal against a conviction for posting a joke message on Twitter dismissed.

First, the bishop…