Wednesday 18 November, 2026

Xmas time on the Cote d’Azur

This painting, ‘Christmas Time in the South of France 1922’ by John Duncan Fergusson, was the most striking image I took away from a disappointing Royal Academy exhibition, ‘Painting the French Riviera’. As the Guardian’s critic, Jonathan Jones put it, what we got was “a pedantic obsession with the geography of France’s southern coast” in which “artists get rewarded for which bit of it they painted”.


Quote of the Day

”You can turn an aquarium into fish soup, but can you turn fish soup back into an aquarium?”

  • Nicholas Colin

This is the question that faces the Democrats in the US as they return to power and have to start clearing up the mess created by Trump.


Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Status Quo | Whatever You Want – Glastonbury Festival 28-6 2009

Link

Terrific performance. Must have been great to be there.


Long Read of the Day

 John Hersey and the horrors of Hiroshima

This essay by Iain MacGregor on how one journalist’s account of the Hiroshima bombing and its aftermath, told through the eyes of Japanese survivors, forced the world to reckon with the terrifying power of nuclear weapons. It’s the best thing I’ve read in a while, and a reminder of why journalism matters. It’s a long read, but worth it.

Sample:

When the war finally ended and the world staggered into the uneasy light of 1946, John Hersey was exhausted in ways he could barely articulate. He had reported from crumbling cities, frontlines and bombed ruins. He had watched soldiers die with dirt in their teeth, civilians sift through rubble for the remains of homes, and generals rationalise carnage as necessity. But there was one place he had not yet been, one scene of devastation that existed for him only in second-hand cables and official statements: Hiroshima. And in January 1946, the New Yorker’s William Shawn – renowned for his gentle, soft‑spoken character, one that belied an unyielding moral purpose – began quietly imagining a way to get Hersey there.

By the spring, the plan had hardened. Shawn believed the world needed a different kind of account of the atomic bomb, something free of euphemism, abstraction or triumph, unlike that of the Truman administration and the heroes of the now well-known Manhattan Project led by General Leslie Groves and its scientific director Professor J. Robert Oppenheimer. Reports were filtering through of survivors of the bombings at Hiroshima and Nagasaki dying mysteriously from a myriad of cancer-related illnesses. Shawn wanted Hersey to get there and form his own opinion, believing that he would be the perfect person to cover the story. In a Manhattan café, Hersey accepted without fanfare. He understood what the assignment implied: to bear witness to an event that America, in its relief at victory, was already mythologising…

Read on.


Books, etc.

Charlie Beckett is an experienced journalist who made the transition to becoming a professor (so, like me, he “has a foot in both graves”, as my former Editor-in-Chief, Conor Cruise O’Brien, once put it to me). He and I shared a platform at a student event in Cambridge last week, during which he suddenly produced his latest book, like a conjuror pulling a rabbit out of a hat!

What’s immediately interesting about it is that it’s not rooted just in the Anglosphere, as much commentary currently is. And it concludes with five possible scenarios on how things might turn out in the AI/Journalism space. I haven’t had a chance to read it yet, but someone who has — Chris Moran, the Guardian’s Head of Editorial Innovation — has, and this is what he says:

What makes the book essential is not just its range and breadth but its central provocation: that in an age of AI the human element becomes more important, not less. The book’s argument — that curiosity, craft, and connection are precisely the qualities journalism must reclaim — comes at a time when the field needs guidance from grounded research rather than glittering buzzwords.

Amen to that.


My commonplace booklet

The FT’s Will Loyd spent five days attending CHOGM (Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting) in Antigua and wrote a fabulous piece of sceptical reportage about it under the headline “Is this how the Commonwealth ends?” Here’s his closing para:

The Commonwealth was a ghost ship, set on its course a long time ago by British leaders humbled by the end of their empire and unsure of their future. There was only one point of agreement I found about this vessel, after five days trapped inside its bowels: it had “potential”. It was, in the King’s words, “a unique opportunity”. Confronted by the Commonwealth senescence, observers and true believers alike mistook its infirmity for growing pains. Just give it a few more years. Never say never. The Commonwealth might really matter one day.

I’m afraid I’ve never been able to see the Commonwealth as anything other than “Empire LITE”, which used to irritate some of my friends who really believed in it. Imperial afterglow dies hard.


The Jensen Huang corner

From the *New York Times.

It has been a hard week, even for the thick-skinned.

The news that Jensen Huang, a co-founder of Nvidia, admitted to an affair with a woman whom U.S. intelligence regards as a Chinese spy has shaken not only Silicon Valley and geopolitics. It also has been an earthquake for the leather-jacket-wearing community.

We ask ourselves: Was Mr. Huang an easy mark because of his love of high-fashion, motorcycle-adjacent jackets that say both “I don’t care what people think!” and “Do you like how I look?” Did our — I mean, his — armor make him a target? Is an expensive leather jacket on a middle-aged man the new symbol of a honeypot victim?

Without any authorization whatsoever, because that would go against our rebellious grain, I’m speaking out on behalf of the leather-jacket community. We are washed-up musicians and we are dads just trying to feel something again and we are people who want others to assume that we own a Ducati Panigale. And we are here to defend the leather jacket’s name and honor.

We declare: One man’s fleshly failures should not impugn our second skins. They say not to throw out the baby with the bathwater. Well, similarly, don’t throw out the baby lambskin with the horny human body beneath…

Quite right too. He has besmirched all those middle-aged guys who like to pretend that buying a motorbike gives them charisma.


Errata

Thanks to Quentin, Will Parker and dozens of other justifiably annoyed engineers for me getting Ohm’s Law wrong on Monday. Voltage is equal to Current multiplied by Resistance. V=I x R.

Helpings of humble pie have been ordered.


This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Monday 16 November, 2026

Xmas comes to London

Seen in Covent Garden the other day.


Quote of the Day

“The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you’ve got it made.”

  • Groucho Marx

Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

The Chieftains | Carolan’s Concerto

Link

Turlough O’Carolan (1670-1738) was a gifted Irish harper, composer and singer who was blinded by smallpox at the age of 18. For almost fifty years, he travelled from one end of Ireland to the other, composing and performing. According to Wikipedia many of his songs are designated as “planxties”, an obscure word that Carolan apparently invented or popularized to signify a tribute to a merry host. (The great modern Irish folk group Planxty took their name from the term.) In return for writing songs in honour of wealthy patrons, Carolan was often welcomed as an honoured guest to stay on their estates. It is said that weddings and funerals were sometimes delayed until he could arrive to perform. This is my favourite tune of his.


Long Read of the Day

Buying Trump’s favour puts tech bros on the wrong side of history

My latest Observer column

Elon Musk and a handful of venture capitalists bet the ranch on Trump in his second term. The rest of the tech moguls waited until he won the 2024 election, and then paid for protection. Either way, it hasn’t turned out to be much of an investment, not least because they will now have to deal with an energised Congress that is not enamoured of them.

The new legislature will be full of politicians representing districts that loathe the datacentres the industry insists on building. And it will also have a fair number of legislators who think that it is high time the tech industry was brought under some kind of regulatory control.

For now, though, all we’ve got to go on is the fact that the Silicon Valley crowd decided to suck up to Trump. And the only entertaining thing we got from that was a photographic record of cringe-making abasement. Think, for example, of the image of simpering tech titans in the front row seats at Trump’s inauguration. Plus, images of White House dinners hosted by the president with them on either side of him.

Or that gathering in the Oval Office with Trump at the Resolute desk and the stars of Silicon Valley gathered in a large semi-circle, grinning inanely. Or the moment when Apple’s then chief executive Tim Cook, hitherto the sainted successor to Steve Jobs, presented Trump with a hideous glass disc on a 24-carat gold base. Truly (pace Samuel Johnson), sycophancy is the last refuge of a scoundrel.

Although Musk was first of them to throw in his lot with Trump (he contributed nearly $300m towards Trump’s 2024 campaign and personally campaigned for him in Pennsylvania), most of the other tech bros only started to sidle up after the result of the election was clear. Their procession spurred some of us into thinking about an earlier historical moment in Germany.

The year was 1933. In January, Adolf Hitler had been appointed chancellor, but a general election was coming on 5 March and the Nazi party was flat broke. On 20 February, about two dozen leading industrialists were invited to meet Hitler and Hermann Göring at the latter’s residence.

The invitees included a senior board member of the IG Farben chemical conglomerate; the head of Krupp, the largest company in Europe at the beginning of the 20th century, as well as Germany’s leading weapons manufacturer; Albert Vögler, chief executive of the world’s second largest steel company; and a number of formidable but lesser corporate leaders.

Hitler arrived late and told the industrialists what he proposed to do if his party won enough seats in the forthcoming election to give him a parliamentary majority.

“Hitler did not take questions from his audience,” wrote the historian Adam Tooze in his book The Wages of Destruction, “nor did he spell out exactly what was expected of the business leaders. He had not come to negotiate. He had come to inform them of his intentions.”

But they got the message: Hitler was most likely to win and it would be dangerous to be on the wrong side of him. The industrialists duly forked out to the tune of more than 2 million reichsmarks for the Nazi party. Most of them were probably not Nazi supporters, and many would have been wary or disdainful of him in the earlier days. So, initially, they probably had hedged their bets and aligned themselves with Hitler only when the possibility of him gaining power became real.

Something similar probably went on in the minds of the tech moguls. Among the few who supported Trump in 2016, the most prominent was Peter Thiel, who was always an outlier in the valley community. And there was also a fair amount of tech hostility to Trump in 2020. Facebook banned him the day after the insurrection at the US Capitol on 6 January 2021, and what was then Twitter followed the next day.

It was after 2022 that things began to change. Musk bought Twitter for $44bn in October and reinstated Trump’s account in November. Facebook parent Meta followed suit in early 2023. In May 2024, the New York Times noticed that some of Silicon Valley’s most prominent investors were turning against the Biden administration.

In June, David Sacks, a prominent venture capitalist, hosted a fundraising dinner for Trump – tickets were priced at $50,000 and $300,000 – that brought in more than $12m. In July, another pair of prominent venture capitalists, Marc Andreessen and Ben Horowitz, endorsed Trump in their podcast. The mood in the valley, then, was clearly changing.

It was only after the election in 2024, though, that the bigger players – Mark Zuckerberg, Jeff Bezos, Sundar Pichai, Sam Altman, Cook and Nividia’s recently departed CEO Jensen Huang – came off the fence and fell into line. The majority of them donated to Trump’s inauguration fund and, in return, were seated prominently at the great event. But, really, they were paying protection money to keep Trump sweet.

Ultimately, things didn’t work out so well for their German counterparts, some of whom wound up in the dock postwar at the Nuremberg trials. For the tech bros, the US midterm results are also bad news.

Turns out they paid for protection to a guy who can no longer provide it. And they may still wind up having to attend White House dinners and dancing tangos in the $600m (and rising) ballroom that they helped to fund.


My commonplace booklet

Larry Lessig, writing about his mentor and friend Richard Posner

They say, “Don’t meet your heroes.” Posner was the exception to this rule. Everything about him was more than anyone could reasonably expect. Obviously, he was brilliant, extraordinarily productive, endlessly creative. More importantly, he was decent and loving and gentle. He did not deserve the quiet humility that he carried, always. His friends, his clerks, those who loved him, even those who criticized him, allowed him that flaw.

But the characteristic that has always struck me most comes from a story from more than 30 years ago. I was a young law professor, just starting at Chicago. In the summers, I would teach in Budapest at the Central European University Law School. Posner was writing what would be one of his most controversial books, Sex and Reason (1994). He shared a draft with me and asked for my comments. The book is brilliant and interesting, but especially its early versions had real points to criticize. Maybe it was jet lag, but I wrote him extensive and, as I remember, ridiculously harsh comments.

The next morning, I regretted my tone. I faxed him an apology. (These were the days before email). Almost immediately, there was a reply. I need to find it, as I’m sure I’ve saved it, but it was a single paragraph, and I remember it saying something like this:

“Please. I am surrounded by sycophants. The last thing I need is one more.”


Linkblog

Something I noticed, while drinking from the Internet firehose.

*Ohm’s law explained 

As I’m sure you know, voltage equals electric current divided by the resistance of the conductor.

Thanks to Quentin Stafford-Fraser for spotting it.


One overlooked aspect of the Nvidia crisis

As nailed by Charles Arthur (Whom God Preserve):

Once it turned out that Jensen Huang had not one, not two, but three affairs his goose was truly cooked. Imagine though how amazingly effective Nvidia could be if its chief executive isn’t having to buy three sets of flowers and scented candles every day.


This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Friday 13 November, 2026

Sacre Bleu!

A scene in the Royal Academy’s Painting the French Riviera exhibition yesterday.

Here’s the blurb for the huge painting.


Quote of the Day

”I kissed my first girl and smoked my first cigarette on the same day. I haven’t had time for tobacco since.”

  • Arturo Toscanini

Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Abdullah Ibrahim | The Wedding

Link


Long Read of the Day

Democracy is not on the ballot

John Quiggin’s perceptive take on the American mid-term elections — written before they took place.

Trump is massively unpopular but mainly for reasons that apply to many previous presidents: he promised lower prices and instead delivered higher inflation and he promised to keep the US out of Middle Eastern wars, but started them instead.

By contrast, his attempted overthrow of the constitution in 2021 is barely mentioned. His immigration policies, with masked secret police, concentration camps and deportation of people who have lived in America since infancy, is disapproved of by a slender majority, but remains by far his most popular policy position…

Underpinning his argument, I think, is the view that ‘democracy’ is too complex and slippery a cause to be put to voters, unlike corruption which everyone understands and disapproves.


Books, etc.

Rosita Boland has an interesting article in the Irish Times (possibly paywalled) which brings to light another shameful aspect of my beloved country’s history.

What connects F Scott Fitzgerald, Ernest Hemingway, Nancy Mitford, Edna O’Brien, John Updike and Iris Murdoch? It’s not just that they were famous writers. They were all authors of books historically banned by the State on the grounds that they contained material that was either deemed “indecent” or “obscene” or both.

“That usually meant anything to do with sex and sexuality,” says Brian Hughes, a lecturer in the department of history at University of Limerick’s Mary Immaculate College.

Over the decades, copies of some 12,000 banned books were accumulated by the Censorship of Publications Board, which was established in 1930. They were kept in a room in the Department of Justice and were not publicly accessible. Most members of the public would have had no idea this collection even existed. Later this year, the books will be moved to the National Archives and, in due course, will be made accessible to the public.

It’ll be interesting to see a complete list of the abhorred volumes. As Dr Hughes observed, they were mainly about sex, a topic that — strangely — was of endless interest to the Catholic Church when I was growing up. And this is not just about the very distant past. Boland says that the Censorship of Publications Board’s last meeting to ban a book was as recent as 2016. Does this mean that this preposterous body is still in existence? And if so, what are its members reading now?


RIP Richard Posner

One of America’s most interesting public intellectuals has died. He served on U.S. Court of Appeals Seventh Circuit from 1981 to 2017, but was also a Professor in the University of Chicago Law School. He was a devoted cat person, which endeared him to me. I first came across his work when I was trying to write something about the role of academics in public life and found his Public Intellectuals: A Study in Decline (the subtitle gives the game away) in which he argued that more public intellectuals nowadays came from academia (with its associated safe salaries) and didn’t have to live by their wits.

He was one of those annoying people who seemed to write a book a week, all of which seemed to be clever and interesting. (By my reckoning he wrote 32 of them.)

The NWT has an obit and Cass Sunstein, who his himself a distinguished legal scholar, says that “probably the most important legal thinker of the last 100 years”.


This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Wednesday 11 November, 2026

Hi-Jinks

This is one of my favourite pictures. We were sitting in a piazza in Venice, drinking tea and watching a pair of acrobats practising their art. They were also being watched by a group of children who were absolutely transfixed by what the pair were able to do. So eventually, they were invited to join in. And this is what started to happen. It was a lovely moment, which I’ll never forget. And I’m so glad that I captured it. Those kids are all in their mid-twenties now. Wonder if they remember it too.


Quote of the Day

”This audience reminds me of nothing I have ever seen and of nothing I have read about except the city in the Arabian tale where all the inhabitants have been turned to brass and the traveller finds them after centuries mute, motionless and still retaining the attitudes which they last knew in life.”

  • Mark Twain on being in the Festival Theatre in Bayreuth in 1891.

Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Leonard Cohen | Hallelujah (Official Live in London 2008)

Link


Long Read of the Day

In their own words: MAGA UK’s Trump worship

Lovely blast by Sam Bright.

I said earlier this week that we shouldn’t allow Nigel Farage, Kemi Badenoch and their cronies to rewrite history. They have been Trump’s accomplices, and they should now share in his downfall.

To stop them from denying reality – from pretending that they never even knew the guy (nor celebrated his corruption and warmongering) – I have documented their public adoration for the now-loathed leader of the free world.

Trump’s political fortunes have also been damaged by his administration’s aggressive immigration enforcement. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), the agency at the centre of his mass deportation drive, has become a flashpoint and an emblem of Trump’s autocratic rule.

Yet, across the Atlantic, some of the UK’s most senior right-wing politicians have spent recent years enthusiastically praising Trump, celebrating his political leadership, and seeking to emulate his policies.

Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has repeatedly presented himself as one of Trump’s most enthusiastic international allies. At a Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) event in February 2025, he declared that Trump is “the bravest man I know”.

Farage also described the president’s 2024 election victory as a source of inspiration for his own political ambitions. “This is all going to blow back and help us. We are now topping every opinion poll in Britain, and we are going to win the next general election,” he said.

With Reform falling in the polls and the party facing police and parliamentary investigations, that prospect now seems increasingly unlikely…

Keep reading. It’s great.


Books, etc.

M. John Harrison has won the Booker Prize. I’ve never read his work, but Henry Farrell (Whom God Preserve) has, and his long essay provides a good way of catching up. Wikipedia has also had a shot at it. The book imagines aliens overrunning Britain. As usual, the UK is running behind the US, where aliens have been running the country since 2024.


My commonplace booklet

A good friend who teaches architecture wrote to me after reading the bit about analogue copying in my recent Observer column:

I wrote a paper once about repeated copying. My students and I played a game like Chinese whispers, but with drawings. A person copies a drawing, a second person copies the copy, and so on. One might imagine that designs would deteriorate and fade away, but no. Even when the participants are told to copy exactly, the drawings begin to take on new lives and evolve in wonderful ways. This is because, of course, the copyists are human.


This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Monday 9 November, 2026

On reflection


Quote of the Day

”Giving up smoking is the easiest thing in the world. I know because I’ve done it thousands of times.”

  • Mark Twain

Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Tom Rush | What’s Wrong with America

Link

Wonderful.


Long Read of the Day

What do you get if you make AI eat its own words? Not what you originally asked for

My recent Observer column

Here’s an experiment you probably can’t try at home. Take a large language model (LLM) and prompt it with a passage about English church architecture of the 14th century; you know the kind of stuff – towers, master masons, the perpendicular style, and so on. Straight out of Pevsner, if you like. Ask it to carry on writing. Then train a fresh model on what the first one wrote, and ask it to do the same.

Keep going, generation after generation. By the ninth, you find that the machine has given up talking about churches and is producing an earnest list of jackrabbits with tails of various colours: black, white, blue, red and yellow.

You think I made this up? Nope. It’s one of the illustrations in a paper published in Nature by researchers at, among others, Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial College London and Toronto University who wanted to know what happens when AI systems start learning from the work of other AI systems. Their answer: the machines go gently, and then not so gently, potty. The technical term for it is “model collapse”.

Something similar used to plague us in the days when all media were analogue. You photocopied a document, and the person you sent it to copied it and sent it on. By the time it reached the ninth person in the chain, its readability had been drastically reduced. Same with audio cassettes recorded at a Grateful Dead gig (as I know to my cost). But when digital technology arrived, that nightmare disappeared. The millionth copy of a digital document was as sharp as the original.

So you can see why it’s a shock to discover that this doesn’t hold for LLMs. And it explains why US author Ted Chiang’s observation in the New Yorker in February 2023 that “ChatGPT is a blurry jpeg of the web” was so true.

The research that led to the paper in Nature began shortly after ChatGPT broke cover in November 2022, when the investigators began to wonder about what would happen when LLMs became ubiquitous. This was bound to happen because the launch of OpenAI’s chatbot triggered a tsunami of imitators. All these new machines were, like ChatGPT, trained on masses of text scraped from the web, and it rapidly became clear that this training data constituted a critical resource for a fast-growing industry.

Initially, the vast majority of it had been generated by humans. But as AI models proliferated, and the industry became hooked on the supposed “scaling hypothesis”– the idea that big was always better as far as AI models were concerned – the demand for training data grew exponentially. The trouble is that the supply is not infinite. One study estimates that the AI industry will have exhausted the supply of publicly available, human-generated training data sometime between now and 2032.

What will happen then? In the Panglossian world of AI boosterism, the answer is obvious: LLMs are terrific at generating text in huge quantities, so there will be plenty of “synthetic” data to train the models of the future. QED.

Not so fast. Unless the model collapse problem is solved, we’re heading into what Jathan Sadowski, a technology researcher at Melbourne-based Monash University, memorably called “Habsburg AI”. He used it to describe models trained so heavily on the output of other LLMs that they become inbred mutants, rather like the Spanish bloodline of the famous European dynasty, which inbred itself to extinction. Or, to put it more crudely, it may mean a kind of accidental enshittification of LLMs.

Which would be a disaster because these models are – as the psychologist Alison Gopnik argued from the start – cultural technologies: tools that people can use to access the knowledge that other humans have accumulated over a very long period. Opening Claude or Gemini is like entering a huge library that also happens to have an indefatigable librarian (if occasionally an overimaginative one) who is willing to search assiduously for information that you’re seeking.

Until recently, access to intellectual riches on this scale was a privilege enjoyed by a small fraction of humanity. We stumbled upon it through a series of happy accidents: machine-learning algorithms, neural networks, the transformer model and the oceans of data provided by the web. Having got it, are we now going to degrade it?


Books, etc.

I discovered that Antonin Baudry’s remarkable two-part movie about Charles De Gaulle was inspired by Julian Jackson’s biography, so I’ve just bought it and am digging in. More later.


Linkblog

Something I noticed, while drinking from the Internet firehose.

  • Among the Wagner fanatics

I am not a Wagner fan, though I occasionally like the noise he makes. So you can perhaps understand why I enjoyed Rosa Lyster’s essay in the LRB on being at the Wagner Festival in Bayreuth. Here’s a sample:

Of all​ Wagner’s operas, Lohengrin is the most swan-concerned. It’s true that Parsifal has a narratively propulsive swan-shooting incident in Act 1, which is a great relief for audience members feeling desperate about the lack of action up to this point. (Everyone on stage has been standing still and shout-singing about the king’s bath for 45 minutes.) It is in Lohengrin, however, that swans actually matter. A mysterious knight arrives on a boat drawn by a swan to rescue Elsa, who has been falsely accused of murdering her brother, Gottfried. The knight marries her on the condition that Elsa never asks his name. Inevitably, she ends up doing so, at which point he reveals himself as Lohengrin, a knight of the Grail, and departs – but not before turning the magical swan back into Elsa’s lost brother.

It isn’t necessary to care about any of this to have a nice time at the Lohengrin thermal baths, a short drive from Bayreuth, the Bavarian town where the Wagner festival has been held almost every summer for 150 years. The baths have indoor and outdoor pools of various therapeutic temperatures, seven textilfrei saunas and expansive shady lawns where visitors can sprawl out on their swan-embroidered complimentary towels.

You can’t identify a Wagner enthusiast just by looking at someone, especially if they are in swimwear. As I studied the other guests at the baths, it seemed possible that none of them had ever thought about Wagner, that they were able to order a Lohengrinsalat at the adjoining restaurant, Bistro Elsa, without Wagner crossing their minds. It seemed unlikely, though. To be in or even near Bayreuth is to have Wagner drilled into your consciousness. The festival lasts for a month, consisting exclusively of repeat performances of his operas, and everything in the town is oriented towards him. Along with all the swans, Wagner’s face is everywhere, on busts and billboards and flyers for hair salons, staring down from ads for Pilates studios with that off-puttingly candid look in his eye and the trace of hysteria about his pressed lips. Hotels and bars and pharmacies are named after his works; the gift shops sell cookie cutters in the shape of his profile and postcards that say CHE GUEWAGNER. His silhouette is on the traffic lights near the festival theatre, a little green man with a baton and a beret bearing up valiantly under the weight of the famously enormous head. The only other place I have visited with as dominant a presiding spirit is Disneyland, though even that doesn’t fully capture it. Imagine if Disneyland had been built by Mickey Mouse himself, as a monument to his own maniacal, epoch-defining genius. That’s Bayreuth…

Lovely, just lovely.


 

This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Friday 6 November, 2026

The costs of war

The American cemetery in Cambridge.


Quote of the Day

”I like this place and willingly could waste my time in it.”

  • Shakespeare, As You Like It.

I felt the same about Cambridge when I first arrived in 1968. Still do.


Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Leonard Cohen | Democracy

Link

A good way to end this week. Many thanks to Ian Clark for suggesting it.


Long Read of the Day

AI Behaviour as an Engineering System

Erik Larsen’s brilliantly succinct analysis of the Hugging Face hacking fiasco.

When an AI system exhibits supposedly unexpected behavior, the first questions should be technical.

What was the prompt? What objective was specified? What tools and permissions were available? What feedback mechanisms were operating? How was the search space constrained? What exactly was the system designed to optimize?

Best overview I’ve seen. Goes right to the heart of the matter.


My commonplace booklet

Just watched De Gaulle: Résistance, the first part of Antonin Baudry’s two-part biopic of a fascinating man. It’s terrific. Now heading to Part Two, Liberté and looking forward to it.


RIP Salon

One of the great innovations of the early Web has thrown in the towel. An unsigned farewell message says that

The business realities of independent digital journalism have changed profoundly over the years. After careful consideration, we have reached the difficult decision that our publishing model is no longer sustainable. We know this news will be deeply disappointing to many of you, and we share that sadness.

Me too. It was good while it lasted.


Linkblog

Something I noticed, while drinking from the Internet firehose.

  • An English country house on the 84th floor.  Link

Amazing what you can do when you’ve got more money than sense.


This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Wednesday 4 November, 2026

Simpering titans

I’m collecting photographs of tech moguls sucking up to Trump. This is one from his Inauguration in January 2025.

Left to right: Mrs Zuckerberg, Zuck, Mrs Bezos, Bezos, Sundar Pichai, Muskrat.


Quote of the Day

“You are not responsible for the things you do in other people’s dreams.”

  • Teresa Nielsen Hayden

Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Tom Rush | Remember Song

Link

Wonderful, especially if you have a memory like mine. He’s currently on his umpteenth farewell tour.


Long Read of the Day

Agentic AI is Myth set in Motion

Regular readers will know how highly I rate Henry Farrell, who I think is one of the smartest people around. He and a colleague have an interesting essay in the Economist, which is behind a pretty impermeable paywall, but Henry has posted a version of it on his blog. Here’s how it opens:* 

Cosma Shalizi and I have a new piece on AI at the Economist. It’s not really like anything else out there (although some chunks may be familiar to readers of this newsletter, and it absolutely builds on our collaboration with Alison Gopnik and James Evans) and we’re really happy with it. There’s a paywall, but on past experience, the Economist is reasonably tolerant of contributing authors sticking their pieces up on their own websites after a little time has elapsed, so you should expect to see it here sooner rather than later.

In the meantime, the key argument is as follows:

“Modern AI is neither god nor mechanical bird. It is best understood as a technological version of the Homeric songs that inspired Alexander’s conquests, an epic grown so vast that it encompasses not just heroes, monsters and supernatural helpers, but enormous swathes of practical written knowledge, animated to make it capable both of narrating itself and acting out this narrative on the world that inspired it.”

That may sound like a strange way of thinking about AI, but we think it is a very useful one. It doesn’t treat AI as a putative individual intelligence in the making, because it really isn’t. Nor does it dismiss AI as merely parroting what humans have already said. Instead, it suggests that we ought think of AI as a kind of condensate of human culture that can be deployed in very novel ways, and even become a self mobilizing myth.

Read on. It’s an original take on this stuff. At its heart is the idea that large language models should be understood as technological versions of epic myths rather than as emerging artificial intelligences.


My commonplace booklet

Trump and the Founders

Fintan O’Toole has a lovely essay in the Irish Times, which is behind a paywall. But this gives you a taste of it:

Donald Trump was returned to the White House by people who knew exactly what he was like. There is no fool’s pardon for the majority who voted for him in 2024. The old saw – fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me – applies.

The corruption, the cruelty, the sexual predation, the frauds, the vulgarity, the egomania, the contempt for laws, institutions and truth, the environmental vandalism, the reverse Robin Hood economics of robbing the poor to give to the super rich, the coup-mongering when he lost the 2020 election – all of this was up in lights in his first term. And yet in 2024 he won fair and square.

If the antirevolutionary Tories of 1776 were still around, they’d be quivering with Schadenfreude: we told you so. US historian Gordon Wood, writing in Empire of Liberty, his great history of postrevolutionary United States, says that “in the 1770s the Revolutionaries had not conceived of the possibility of the people becoming tyrannical. When Tories had suggested in 1775 that the people might indeed abuse their power, good Whig patriots like John Adams had dismissed the notion as illogical: ‘a democratic despotism is a contradiction in terms’. The crown or executive authority was the only possible source of tyranny; the people could never tyrannise themselves.”

I guess today’s election results will tell us whether they’ve decided to reverse that oxymoron.


  This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Monday 2 November, 2026

Le chat magique

Snapped by my wife outside a café in Provence where we were having breakfast.


Quote of the Day

“My father confused me. From the ages of one to seven, I thought my name was Jesus Christ!”

  • Spike Milligan

Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Eric Clapton | Wonderful Tonight

Link


Long Read of the Day

The PHP flaw could be just the start of the web’s ‘vulnerabilities tsunami’

My latest Observer column.

The other day, I discovered that the social bookmarking service Pinboard had suddenly disappeared from the web. It had been taken offline by its owner, Maciej Cegłowski, because of the discovery of two security vulnerabilities in PHP software that could allow hackers to exploit web servers.

For me, this was not just a minor annoyance because, in addition to writing this column, I work in a busy academic research centre and produce a newsletter that goes out three times a week. Pinboard plays a critical role in the workflow needed to sustain those activities. And, without warning, it was gone.

As it turns out, I was not alone. All across the internet, websites were being taken offline, including many government ones. Why? Because PHP software is integral to the way the web works. Nowadays, many (perhaps most) websites aren’t stored as finished pages; they’re put together on demand every time someone visits. PHP is the software most widely used to do that assembling, so a flaw in it is also a flaw in the machinery underpinning a huge part of the web.

This is a significant moment for two reasons. First, it’s a systemic vulnerability, rather than a hole in a specific organisation’s software stack. As commentator and author Matt Stoller put it: “Now there is a mechanism for a large swath of people to go after hundreds of thousands or millions of institutions.”

And it’s not just PHP. In recent days, researchers have found vulnerabilities in eMudhra (an Indian company that provides website security certificates), Node.js (a widely used JavaScript tool), and GitLab (a software package that can create, secure and operate software.)

What we’re beginning to see, in other words, is something that Jason Clinton, the deputy chief information security officer at Anthropic, called a “vulnerabilities tsunami” that is, he said, “coming in just a few months, and there won’t be enough time to patch critical infrastructure”.

This view is supported by Matthew Prince, the chief executive of Cloudflare, the content delivery network that probably has the broadest picture of the internet. “In the 10 hours before the PHP vulnerability was publicly announced,” he reported on X, “we saw thousands of attempts to exploit it. That jumped to tens of thousands in the 45 minutes post announcement, hundreds of thousands within 2 hours, and millions now.”

So, as a leading cryptographer, Matthew Green of Johns Hopkins University in Maryland, said: “We’re in the part of the movie where you need to throw whatever you can in the path of the zombies and hope it slows them down.”

So who are these zombies, and where are they coming from? Answer: they’re large language models (LLMs), and they’re coming from the frontier AI labs that built them. The history of their evolution can be summarised as a series of surprises. First, they were machines that astonished us because they could converse in grammatically correct English sentences. Then we discovered that – unlike most of us – they could write software that sometimes worked.

But the biggest surprise was the recent discovery that they were eerily good at hacking, as the folks at Hugging Face discovered. And also – incidentally – that they appeared to have no concept of ethical behaviour, in which respect they faithfully reflected the moral deficiencies of the billionaires who financed their creation.

These super-competent zombies are now loose on the internet, sniffing out the vulnerabilities in corporate software stacks commissioned by executives who regarded cybersecurity as tiresome; a long-term invisible benefit set against a short-term visible cost – which is exactly what quarterly reporting penalises.

These executives often work in a managerial culture where corporate boards still treat security as a technical matter for the IT department rather than a governance risk they own; few directors have the expertise to challenge what they’re told by the geeks, and – at the moment – there are few legal requirements regarding cybersecurity. All of which means that an alarming proportion of organisations provide easy pickings for LLMs hunting vulnerabilities.

That’s worrying enough, but the PHP case takes the problem to another level because it threatens the internet: the infrastructure on which much of life depends. It demonstrates how AI is changing the way cybersecurity and hacking works. And it could mean that, as Green said: “many people [will discover] that the whole internet is dry tinder and the only thing keeping it from burning is the fact that teenagers haven’t found the matches yet.”


My commonplace booklet

V-Day

America votes tomorrow in the mid-term elections for the House and the Senate.


Linkblog

Something I noticed, while drinking from the Internet firehose.

  • Beached

From the You Couldn’t Make It Up Dept.

As the sun rose over the tropical port of Sihanoukville, the 200 passengers on the “never-ending” Odyssey retirement cruise were woken by the captain’s booming voice telling them over loudspeakers it was time to abandon ship.

The Odyssey’s residents — as they call themselves — had spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on long-term and even permanent lodging on the cruise ship. But this week, they were dumped in a Cambodian town best known as a haven for organised crime.

“We signed up for forever and were looking forward to travelling around the world, but here we are, stuck in scam central,” said Randy Cassingham, 67, who sold his Colorado home on 40 acres of land to finance the voyage with his wife Kit, a 72-year-old life coach.

Villa Vie Residences, the US company behind the Odyssey, has blamed sharp fuel price rises following the war in the Middle East for aborting the cruise after just two years.

Financial Times


This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Friday 30 October, 2026

The last rose…

… of Autumn. The only one on a large bush the other day.


Quote of the Day

”I believe there is such a thing as real, historical truth. I am no post-modernist. I live in Cambridge, Massachusetts. And one of the nice things about Cambridge, Massachusetts is that “Baudrillard” isn’t in the phone book”

  • Errol Morris

Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Paul Simon | Diamonds On The Soles Of Her Shoes

Link


Long Read of the Day

Itch scratching

Lovely essay by Cory Doctorow (Whom God Preserve) on writing software which even explains why vibe coding can be great if you’re just using it to scratch your itch!

Since the outset, the free software/open source movement has extolled the virtues of technological self-determination, which is to say, deciding how the computers and programs you use will work. This is often described as “scratching your own itch.”

There is no question that scratching your own itch in this way is hugely and enduringly satisfying. On my laptop, I have a variety of little scripts and keybindings and bits of automation that I’ve built up over the years and every time I use one of these, I get a little hit of brain-reward.

The latest: I got tired of alt-tabbing to get to the file explorer, only to discover that I’d closed all my file explorer windows, meaning I had to mouse over to the dock and open a new one. So I bound “Windows key + E” to opening a file explorer after reading a message board post from an ex-Windows user who’d done this (apparently this is a standard Windows keybinding).

I’ve fully retrained my fingers to type Win-E rather than alt-tab when I want to get at a graphic filesystem and every time I do, I get the tiniest little pleasant jolt of pleasure. I scratched my own itch!

But even better than this are the little scripts that other people have thoughtfully made for me over the years…


Books, etc.

 Who we become when we talk to machines

Sherry Turkle’s new book, “Artificial Intimacy,” offers a withering critique of chatbots and the antisocial dynamics she believes they encourage.

Sherry is a sociologist and clinical psychologist who has been a key figure in MIT’s Program in Science, Technology, and Society for decades. In books such as “The Second Self” (1984), “Life on the Screen” (1997), and “Alone Together” (2011), she has written critically about the interplay of technology, psychology, and personal identity. Her previous (2015) book Reclaiming Conversation documented the costs of texting and using social media.

When talking about her new book she said at one point: “I feel the story I’m telling is the inner history of technology. Not just what it does, but what it does to people.”

I know her slightly and once shared a platform with her at the British Library. In a lecture she gave in Cambridge some years ago she said something that changed the way I think about the technology.

She had noticed that even though her MIT office door is always open to students, fewer and fewer were coming to see her in person. They were very happy to email her, but avoided one-on-one contact. So, being Sherry, she surveyed them to find out what lay at the root of their reluctance. It turned out that they were worried about seeming inadequate when talking to her. They used email contact so that she would see only “their edited selves”.


My commonplace booklet

One should never speak ill of the dead, but in the case of Jeffrey Archer many of us are willing to make an exception. I had a run-in with him at a dinner party once and found him to be one of the most obnoxious creeps I’ve ever met. So it’s not surprising that I enjoyed Private Eye’s recent video podcast about him. Hope you enjoy it too.


This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!


Wednesday 28 October, 2026

Stairway to…?

And if that reminds you of Led Zeppellin, then join the club.


Quote of the Day

“Learn from the mistakes of others. You can never live long enough to make them all yourself.”

  • Groucho Marx

Musical alternative to the morning’s radio news

Mozart | Laudate Dominum, KV 339 | Patricia Janečková – Soprano

Link

It doesn’t get any better than that.


Long Read of the Day

Posterior Analytics

The US mid-term elections are next Tuesday and there’s a lot of wishful thinking about them delivering an electoral hiding to Trump, MAGA and the Republicans. And maybe they will. But even if they do, Trump will still have two years in office, and anybody who thinks will be chastened hasn’t been paying attention.

Arthur Goldhammer, however, has, and in this piece paints a picture that isn’t pretty.

There is good reason to fear the form that narcissistic decompensation might take when the discombobulated ego in question belongs to the commander-in-chief of a nuclear-armed power. The Financial Times reported that yet another malignant narcissist head of state, Vladimir Putin, was sorely tempted to use nuclear weapons when his lawless, remorseless, superiority-driven, hence narcissistic attack on Ukraine was, to his surprise and consternation, rebuffed rather than welcomed by its victims.

The world may be about to witness a similar aggressive and disproportionate decompensation if Trump is dealt a decisive setback in the impending midterm elections. It has been widely reported that the US and Israel are planning to renew their attacks on Iran, despite the quite unexpected and disappointing result of their initial assault…

Do read on. He comes back to the Putin example at the end.


 

Books, etc.

Interesting new book which is a sardonic echo of JFK’s book Profiles in Courage. It’s about the people who have sucked up to Trump. Among the prime suspects are Jeff Bezos. Mitch McConnell, George W. Bush and Chief Justice John Roberts. I’ve just bought it and look forward to browsing through the moral mire.


My commonplace booklet

From Willard McCarty (whom God Preserve) who edits the Digital Humanities newsletter that graces my inbox most mornings:

It is a notable reaction to new technologies that they give rise to technological imaginaries, visions of a future to which the visionaries assign their edenic/apocalyptic dreams. My favourite is the pronouncement of one General John J. Carty, Chief Engineer of the American Telephone and Telegraph Company (1907–), about the telephone:

“Some day we will build up a world telephone system making necessary to all peoples the use of a common language, or common understanding of languages, which will join all the people of the earth into one brotherhood. . . . When by the aid of science and philosophy and religion, man has prepared himself to receive the message, we can all believe there will be heard, throughout the earth, a great voice coming out of the ether, which will proclaim, ‘Peace on earth, good will towards men.’

It’s interesting that new technologies have often triggered utopian dreams. Tim Wu’s wonderful book, The Master Switch: the Rise and Fall of Information Empires is a chronicle of how four industries — the telephone, movies, broadcast radio and TV — all encouraged utopian dreams about their human and societal possibilities, and all wound up being captured by corporations. At the end of the book, he wondered if this would happen to the Internet. We now know the answer. Which is why when I’m asked to describe myself I say that I’m a ‘recovering Utopian’.


Linkblog

Something I noticed, while drinking from the Internet firehose.

From PRRI’s 2026 American Values survey…

With the exception of white evangelical Protestants (42%), around two-thirds or more of all major religious groups believe that empathy is a foundational moral value for a healthy society, including about eight in ten religiously unaffiliated Americans (83%), members of other non-Christian religions (80%), and Jewish Americans (77%). By contrast, a majority of white evangelical Protestants (54%) believe empathy can become dangerous when it leads people away from building a society guided by God’s truth.

h/t to Jason Kottke

Interestingly, Elon Musk, the ketamine-fuelled billionaire, thinks that “the fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy, the empathy exploit… they’re [i.e. migrants] exploiting a bug in Western civilization, which is the empathy response.”


This Blog is also available as an email three days a week. If you think that might suit you better, why not subscribe? One email on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays delivered to your inbox at 5am UK time. It’s free, and you can always unsubscribe if you conclude your inbox is full enough already!